Mysterious Morgan Township

By Michael Kleen

With a colorful past that includes long-lost towns, determined hog thieves, and cemetery lore, Morgan Township in northeastern Coles County is one of the area’s most interesting destinations. The township is around nine miles long, four and a half miles wide in the north and a mere one and a half miles wide in the south. The Embarras River valley and timberland lay along its eastern border, and the familiar prairie lay along its western border.

Morgan Township was named after David Morgan, a Kentuckian who arrived in Coles County in 1834, but that part of the county was heavily populated by American Indians prior to his arrival. Today, it is home to the communities of Bushton and Rardin, as well as acres of pristine, natural wilderness.

According to the History of Coles County, 1879, a number of Indian burial grounds are scattered around the township, although none have been excavated by archeologists. In 1877 or ‘78, a man named Henry Curtis dug up a human skull, as well as a few other bones, while looking for bait worms. The skull possessed a bullet-like hole in the back. Curtis, shocked by his discovery, quickly reburied the skeleton and covered the site with rocks. It was never determined to whom the skeleton belonged.
[Read more...]

About these ads

The St. Omer “Witch’s Grave”

By Michael Kleen

St. Omer Cemetery and the small, defunct village of the same name probably would have been forgotten a century ago had it not been for one unusual family monument and a misprinted date. As is often the case in Coles County, these peculiar circumstances gave birth to an obscure but enduring legend. According to local lore, Caroline Barnes, one of four people buried under the massive stone, was put to death for practicing witchcraft. It is said that no pictures can be taken of her monument, and that it glows on moonless nights.

The Barnes family monument is difficult to describe. Some say it looks like a crystal ball on top a pyre. Conventionally, orbs in cemetery art represent faith, and logs, or tree trunks, are fairly common imagery representing growth and enduring life. This particular gravestone is rare, but similar monuments can be found in several central Illinois cemeteries, including Union Cemetery in northeastern Coles County.

Why do some people believe a witch is buried here? The only evidence for the legend seems to be the gravestone’s dramatic design, the way local citizens grow nervous whenever the story is mentioned, and most strikingly, Caroline’s impossible date of death chiseled in the granite: February 31. The monument also faces north and south, while most headstones are oriented east-west.

[Read more...]

Pemberton Hall and the Ghost of Mary Hawkins

By Michael Kleen

The legend of Eastern Illinois University’s Pemberton Hall is, by far, the most famous ghost story to come out of Coles County. A variation of a well-known  folktale called “the Roommate’s Death,” it has been passed down by generations of young women at EIU and has appeared in dozens of books. One night, it is said, a deranged janitor attacked and killed a student on the fourth floor. Her ghost, or the ghost of the dorm mother who discovered her body, now haunts the hall. Over the years, Pemberton Hall’s own history contributed to this story, creating a unique tale beloved by students and alumni alike.

In 1907, the Appropriations Committee of the State legislature passed a bill to provide $100,000 to build a women’s dormitory at Eastern Illinois State Normal School. The dorm was named after state senator Stanton C. Pemberton, a strong proponent of the bill. The first dorm director for Pemberton Hall was the now infamous Mary Hawkins, who served in that position from 1910 to 1917. She was thought to be very strict and would not allow “her girls” to go to social functions without a chaperone. During the early half of the twentieth century, women attending the college and staying in Pemberton Hall would, in addition to their classes, learn basic housekeeping skills and serve dinner to the college deans on some occasions. They were not allowed outside after 7:30pm on weekdays and 10pm on weekends. Mary Hawkins personally doled out punishment for any infraction until she left the college in 1917. Ironically, Miss Hawkins died on October 29, 1918 at the Kankakee State Mental Hospital a year after leaving her position as “Dorm Mother” from complications stemming from syphilis.

[Read more...]

The Mad Gasser of Mattoon

By Michael Kleen

It was September 1, 1944, the fifth anniversary of the opening salvos of World War 2. American GIs had been fighting their way across northern France for three months. Across the nation, the press churned out lurid accounts of Nazi rocket attacks on London, and comic books depicting Nazi thugs battling super heroes with space age weapons were sold at dime store counters. In Peoria, Illinois, the search for a German prisoner of war who had escaped from nearby Camp Ellis ended that afternoon in a local tavern.

At a nondescript home on Marshall Avenue in Mattoon, Elsie Kearney and her three year old daughter Dorothy readied for bed. Her sister, Martha, occupied the living room and two young children were asleep in other parts of the house. As Mrs. Kearney lay with her eyes closed, she began to smell an overpowering, sweet scent she assumed came from the flowers outside her window. It seemed harmless at first, until she felt her lower body go limp and her legs became unresponsive. “Martha!” she screamed. “Martha, help!”

After a few agonizing moments in which the paralysis slowly climbed up Mrs. Kearney’s body, her sister burst into the room. “What’s wrong?” she asked, frantically throwing on the light.

Mrs. Kearney explained that she was unable to move from the bed. Martha noticed the unusual smell, determined it must be coming from outside, and closed the window. She then rushed over to a neighbor’s house and told him to call the police. The neighbor, Mr. Karl Robertson, searched the Kearney’s yard, but failed to find anything out of the ordinary. The police had similar results, and Mrs. Kearney recovered the use of her limbs shortly before midnight. Her daughter was also ill, and remained so until the next morning.

Meanwhile, a friend had gone out to find Mr. Kearney, who was working late as a taxi driver. He was unable to return home until 12:30, when he noticed a man lurking near his wife’s bedroom window. He later described the man as tall, wearing dark clothes and a knit cap. He shouted and rushed toward the intruder, but the intruder disappeared into the darkness. Mattoon police officers were again summoned to the home, but found nothing.

[Read more...]

Mysterious Lafler-Ennis Cemetery

By Michael Kleen

It is a legend so obscure that its only press has been the first half of a sentence in an article published in 1977, and a cemetery so little known that it only appears on a county cemetery map dating back to 1980. It is a place that might have been forgotten entirely had it not been an ideal proving ground for fraternity and sorority pledges. Lafler-Ennis Cemetery is surrounded by woods and the Charleston Stone Quarry, near the banks of the Embarras River, and accessible by way of a gravel path announced by a hand-painted sign. It even contains the grave of a Mary Hawkins, only this Mary Hawkins died in 1851 in infancy, and was therefore not the Mary Hawkins of Pemberton Hall fame.

“Aside from the alledged [sic] werewolf who roams the Charleston Quarry…” began an October 28, 1977 Eastern News article entitled “Ghosts Roam Local Haunts.” The reporter went on to describe the ghost of Pemberton Hall and a haunted house in Charleston, but never elaborated on the werewolf story, as though it was already well known to her readers. Such a cursory mention could be easily dismissed, but then so could the reports in the 1950s of a ghost in Old Main, an obscure story that has all but vanished from the minds of students and local residents alike.

[Read more...]

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 277 other followers